Even before the tragic events of
September 11, Kazakhstan and other Central Asian nations such as
Azerbaijan, Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan were beginning to receive
greater attention from the United States government, primarily
because of their significant petroleum and other mineral
resources. Since September 11, that interest has intensified,
mainly because of security concerns highlighted by the military
campaign in Afghanistan and the overall war against terrorism.
From both perspectives, the United States has important national
interests relating to Kazakhstan specifically and Caspian Basin
region more generally. These interests have been extensively
articulated by the Bush Administration and members of Congress
this year. They are likely to be further clarified when President
Nursultan Nazarbayev meets with President Bush December 21 at the
White House.
International Security
Kazakhstan borders both Russia
and China and is a close neighbor of both Iran and Afghanistan. As
Senator Sam Brownback has observed - well before the military
campaign in Afghanistan – Kazakhstan is "caught in a tough
neighborhood."
During his visit to Kazakhstan
this month, Secretary of State Colin Powell acknowledged the
country’s political and diplomatic support for the war on
terrorism, and its military support in the form of overflight
clearances. While it has not been necessary to take up Kazakhstan’s
offer to use its military bases, the country’s transportation
infrastructure and other facilities could play a significant role
in humanitarian relief and the reconstruction of Afghanistan.
Well before September 11,
Kazakhstan was acknowledged as a possible buffer against Islamic
fundamentalism. Indeed, the Islamic tradition in Central Asia in
general has been a very tolerant one. The Taliban's variety of
Islam has had little attraction to most inhabitants of Central
Asia, who widely accept the idea of a secular state.
The United States also has a
strong interest in working with Central Asian governments to
combat illicit drugs and to prevent the smuggling of materials
that could be used to develop weapons of mass destruction. The
Federal Bureau of Investigation recently opened an office in
Kazakhstan to serve these purposes.
The United States and Kazakhstan
recently made significant progress on what the Department of
Energy has called "one of the world's largest and most
successful nonproliferation projects" – securing a
stockpile of weapons-grade plutonium large enough to make roughly
400 nuclear bombs. That project builds on a record of security
cooperation between the two countries that began when Kazakhstan
agreed to denuclearize after the collapse of the Soviet Union ten
years ago, and continued through Operation Sapphire, during which
Kazakhstan shipped 600kg of weapon-grade uranium to the United
States to remove an urgent proliferation threat.
In the past decade, Russia
occasionally has attempted to exert influence on Kazakhstan and
other former Soviet states, particularly with regard to energy
matters. During his confirmation hearing in January, Secretary of
State Colin Powell noted that, "we have to make it clear to
the Russians that even though they may have concerns in the
periphery of the old Soviet Union and now the periphery of Russia,
they cannot act in a heavy-handed way, and they cannot intimidate
these countries, and they cannot threaten these countries, and
they should not think about trying to re-create the old Soviet
Union in some smaller way. This will not further their interests
in the West."
On a more positive note, the
recent warming trend in US-Russian relations bodes well for
America’s efforts to enhance its relations with the Central
Asian nations – primarily because it could imply a relaxation of
the constraints (whether real or imagined) that former Soviet
states perceive to emanate from Moscow’s foreign policy.
Energy Security
Natural resources, particularly
oil and gas, currently provide the greatest opportunities for
strengthening ties between the United States and Central Asia, and
Kazakhstan in particular. To date, the most senior US official to
speak at length about Kazakhstan has been Vice President Dick
Cheney. Commenting this July on the Administration=s comprehensive
national energy plan, Vice President Cheney stressed the
importance of Kazakhstan in the context of diversifying foreign
oil supplies. "We need to develop projects to get pipelines
built …. so that we can get access to the oil, get it into the
international market, that will help stabilize prices and
diversify supply."
Indeed, as the United States and
Russia seek to build upon the commercial aspects of their
relationship, the energy resources of the former Soviet Union
could in fact serve as basis for international cooperation. That
was the message Secretary of Commerce Donald Evans sought to
convey in his recent statement regarding the Caspian Pipeline
Consortium, a $2.6 billion project that built a 935-mile crude oil
pipeline running from the Tengiz oil field in Kazakhstan to the
Russian Black Sea port of Novorossiysk Referring to the project,
Secretary Evans declared that "it tells the world that the
United States, Russia, and Central Asian states are cooperating to
build prosperity and stability in this part of the world."
Proven oil reserves in
Azerbaijan and Kazakhstan are about 20 billion barrels, almost
equivalent to those of the United States. These figures could
increase significantly as exploration continues. For example,
initial results of exploration in Kazakhstan’s Kashagan field
indicate the potential oil reserves are comparable to those of
Prudhoe Bay in Alaska.
Current exports from the region
are about 800,000 barrels of oil per day, in part due to limited
export route options. DOE estimates that exports could increase by
1.8 million barrels of oil per day by 2005, as export routes, such
as the Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan (BTC) and Caspian Pipeline Consortium
oil pipelines are fully functional.
Kazakhstans energy potential
argues for strengthened cooperation and commercial dialogue
between senior officials of both the U.S. and Kazakhstan. In this
regard, an energy working group that can help clear obstacles to
implementing commercial projects could prove very useful.
Democracy and Civil Society
The strategic geopolitical
position and commercial attractions of Kazakhstan, and other
nations in Central Asia, should not divert U.S. attention from
promoting democratic values and assisting in the development of
market economies in the region. Kazakhstan has made substantial
progress in implementing economic and political reforms since
achieving independence ten years ago. But it will require
sustained effort by Kazakhstan’s leaders to overcome the tragic
legacy of seventy years of Communist rule. As the dominant
political figure in the country, President Nazarbayev will play
the key role in setting the tone and direction of Kazakhstan’s
political evolution. Indeed, he could help make Kazakhstan a model
for the region. The U.S. can also assist in this process, through
the democracy building efforts of organizations like the
International Republican Institute and National Democratic
Institute. Lastly, repeal of the outdated Jackson-Vanik sanctions
– as already championed by key members of the U.S. Congress –
and official recognition of Kazakhstan as a "market
economy" in 2002 could help usher in a new era in US-Kazakh
relations.